Thank you that was helpful because while I have read your thread having it concisely here is good. I appreciate you did that.
There are some things we have in common here. H and I were also friends with benefits for almost a year before we decided we would date. We had incredible sex and conversations but we dated other people and even discussed those potential people. I actually broke it off with him once because I met someone I really liked. He was hung up on a girl at work that toyed with him for a long time.
Then almost immediately after becoming a couple because we had always been open about our fantasies we started to experiment with swinging. Due to low self esteem I continued to do it. The only benefit about it that I liked was the hysterical bonding we would experience afterwards.
I think maybe where she and I diverge is I was conditioned to believe growing up that a woman needs to stay on top of sex because a husband won’t feel loved and will stray. I believed it so much that in the aftermath of my affair I actually defended sex as a requirement for a long time. I got in a lot of threads about it and prolifically said it was how to heal the marriage. I was wrong, very wrong about that. I actually think it would have been healthier to express this wasn’t working for me, and while she might be doing that more she is going about it in a very bad way. Bottling it up until it comes out like a child having a tantrum.
Another way I relate to what you are saying is up to my affair, I was working as a CEO for a small company, had just about finished raising three kids, was helping my husband start a business, and was putting in 18 hour days. I would have these meltdowns with my husband because after a year of sleep and relaxation deprivation I couldn’t take it anymore. I was told basically to suck it up, that if we just made this work we would be financially feee to do whatever we wanted. (He was right about that, I was able to leave my job and we have been traveling this past year) So I continued to help but due to exhaustion I was starting to drop a lot of balls. This went against my perfectionist nature and destroyed my ego as he would get upset when I said I didn’t have time to take care of something. I didn’t though, I still was running our entire household and was the breadwinner at this point.
Enter the affair. It felt good. Very good. I escaped deeper and deeper into it because I couldn’t manage my life. Some of my entitlement came from the long hours and not feeling seen or heard. I was on autopilot. I was diagnosed with emotional exhaustion weeks before I slept with this other person.
My husband saw it as a sexual awakening too. Because it’s at that time how and why he would have an affair - the sexual frustration. (Even though he went on and had an affar
Or for other reasons that didn’t include that. I was having sex with him daily) But again, motivations of an affair are usually far removed from the whys. It wasn’t a sexual awakening it was escapism. Because I never communicated well enough to build a life I didn’t have to escape from. In fact I don’t think I had an awareness of a lot of my needs at all.
I can’t give you an explanation for why she was so toxic around sex from the early part of your marriage. General wisdom is that there is a polarization that happens that often causes that but it’s difficult to go back and say what happened over a decade prior.
I can tell you that while I would say we had a good sex life prior to my affair, that was defined by I had orgasms. We had sex frequently and I mostly climaxed. So to me, it was successful. But I was very much like your wife I wanted to do what worked. Usually it was giving him oral and me using my own fingers, or a very specific position. We might do other stuff but that was always incorporated because it was "successful"
That didn’t come from anywhere other than I knew he would want to have sex until I climaxed. I wanted to make sure I could do that because otherwise it would go until I was sore, or we would be back at it later. He couldn’t see sex as successful without it and in many ways that’s what made me ultimately pull away there too. For many women orgasms are elusive at times and he didn’t feel sex was successful without them. This led to my own sexual dysfunction.
How I define successful sex now is nothing like that. Our sex life now is intimate, loving, exciting, we mix it up constantly. If I don’t get there, it’s okay with both of us. I can and very much do enjoy what did happen. But we had to approach this much differently and due to his affair this has been a pretty recent development over the past year. I never knew how much joy sexual fulfillment was until we came to this place. The requirement had put another dysfunction on top of our existing ones.
So why am I telling you this? Because I didn’t understand at the time that was the problem and I am trying to illustrate your wife doesn’t understand herself either. I shared with you in a prior post, but from about six months before the affair until about six months or so after I had the female version of impotency. I honestly just felt our marriage was dead. I resented him over it. But it was my issue cause by a combo of lack of awareness and not advocating for my own needs. Sounds like you both do that.
She needs to find her issues, awareness is honestly half the battle. I am sorry this is what you endured. However, until she has perspective over why things were this way it isn’t that she won’t change it, it’s that she can’t change it. She has to resolve the idea that her resentments belong to her because she didn’t do the work along the way to try to effecting address them.
My whole purpose of writing what I did was so it could be investigated. Once I saw the ways I was not enjoying sex or our marriage, recognizing my resentment, I could approach it differently. But by that time I had created a lot of damage in my h and so we did the same things you are doing now- artificially fixing it with a requirement that puts more pressure in a very sensitive area.
I had a lot of sex under duress. It was my own perceptions that made it duress, but fear of losing my husband was never not there. I think your wife is experiencing that. She knows things were always fucked up but she doesn’t understand why it was that way and she likely has unconsciously blamed you a lot for it. But she sees the fights to be about that totally because she hasn’t dealt with being introspection in the right ways here. She may also want to take some time evaluating whether her IC person is a good fit, because it takes a good one to help see you need to dig there.
That’s the key about ws’s we are people who sleep walk through life with little introspection. When you say childlike, that’s accurate. To tie a bow around it, my picture of how we got married is that I was loyal. He couldn’t land the girl at work, and since I wasn’t sufficient for him we had to do swinging. For the rest of our marriage I held that inadequacy without realizing it.
It was easy to think I was there as a convenience to him. I have shown a lot of vulnerability in writing this because it’s hard for me to admit to strangers I was so stupid and blind. My husband married me because he loves me, and if I had been looking at things with appreciation instead of unworthiness I would have been able to see it. I know what a foolish child I was.
[This message edited by hikingout at 6:24 PM, Wednesday, August 24th]