"you are gonna throw everything away coz I won’t give you [oral sex]?"…
You should do some Googling on the concept of DARVO. That statement is a master class in DARVO. Almost like she was prepped to deliver this virtuoso stanza, perhaps (ahem) by a counselor who is coaching her with the over-arching plan to manage you.
You can see the road map she is prepared to follow. You file divorce, and she tells all of your friends and relatives that you are divorcing her because she won’t give you a blowjob. She will make you out to be shallow and selfish.
The answer is that she "threw everything away" when she decided that she would rather betray you sexually with your friend than honor her marriage vows.
Since then, you have been considering whether to give her an opportunity to repair what she has broken. But in the process, you've been learning more about her, and you're not sure you love or even like the person who would make the choices she has made with respect to you.
-She chose to marry you and promise you a lifetime of fidelity.
-She then chose to impose abnormally restrictive sexual boundaries within the context of your marriage.
-She then chose to secretly redefine her half of the marriage as an open marriage, arrogating to herself the freedom to have sex, repeatedly and enthusiastically, with another man, a friend of yours.
-In that context, she then chose to give the other man a wider range of enthusiastic sexual experiences than she has offered you.
-She has now chosen to ask you to simply accept this as a fait accompli and return to the status quo prior to the affair.
In so choosing, your wife was the first of the two of you to choose to leave the marriage. The elephant in the room here, that I don't think anybody has discussed, is that, from what I can glean from your posts, your WW enjoyed herself in the context of her A. It was fun and thrilling for her. She had her cake and ate it too.
"No, I'm not 'throwing it all away' because you won't give me oral sex. I am sexually frustrated in our marriage, but this is not the reason I'm divorcing you. I am divorcing you because you committed adultery with my friend, in a manner that was despicable and disgusting, never mind profoundly humiliating to me as a man. In processing this I've seen sides of you that I didn't previously realize existed and, quite frankly, I do not wish to remain married to a woman like you who would choose to do the things you have done."
The hypocrisy of her DARVO statement is here:
and then the killer "all you guys are the same… everything is about sex!"
Say what? SHE is the one who chose to have extramarital sex, not you. She is the one who injected sexual betrayal into the marriage not you. As between the two of you, she is the one who has made this "all about sex". Affairs are precisely about sex. She ended your marriage so she could give blowjobs to your friend. The fallacy in her DARVO is the straw man fallacy. You aren’t throwing everything away. She already did that.
By the way, there was some speculation about her "whys" above. Specifically, the "why" she won't give you blowjobs now (because she associates "spicy" with "bad"). I don't buy that for a minute, but if she does associate "spicy" with "bad", it is because of her intentional choices. She chose to create that association. Why should you bear the burden? It is often said here, don't set yourself on fire to keep somebody else warm.
My view is consistent with a truism repeated here all the time: fundamentally, cheaters cheat because they want to. Your wife gave your friend blowjobs, returning repeatedly for months, because she wanted to. It's really that simple.
As to you wanting a blowjob, the answer is that you want the one specific species of blowjob that she can’t possibly ever give you. Specifically, you want a blowjob from somebody who actually desires to and enjoys providing it, which is precisely the one thing she can never give you. No matter what she does going forward, there is no way for her to give you a blowjob without you at least wondering whether she's forcing herself to do it out of a sense of duress. Oral sex is functionally off the table for your present marriage, forever.
[This message edited by Butforthegrace at 9:17 PM, Wednesday, March 15th]